Pool to Deck Conversion vs. Pool Fill-In: Which Option Is Better?

Written by Freedom Decks | Aug 1, 2025 11:24:38 PM

Making the Right Choice for Your Backyard Transformation

If you’re considering removing an unused swimming pool, you’ve likely encountered two common options: pool fill-in or a pool to deck conversion. While both create more usable yard space, they differ significantly in cost, safety, flexibility, and long-term impact on your property value. Understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision.

What Is a Pool Fill-In?

A pool fill-in involves partially demolishing the pool structure, filling it with dirt or debris, and compacting the area.

This is often chosen for its lower upfront cost, but there are hidden issues homeowners should consider:

Structural Concerns: Buried concrete can leave voids under the ground, leading to uneven settling over time.
Restricted Future Construction: Building over a filled-in pool area is often prohibited by local building codes.
Negative Impact on Home Value: Buyers may hesitate to purchase a home with a known buried pool structure.
Permanence: Restoring a filled-in pool is typically impossible without a full reconstruction costing tens of thousands of dollars.

What Is a Pool to Deck Conversion?

A pool to deck conversion transforms your existing pool into a safe, level, usable patio space—without demolition. Freedom Decks uses a proprietary bracket system and composite decking to create a strong, slip-resistant surface that’s fully removable.

Why this solution works for so many homeowners:

- - Quick Transformation: In just 2 to 5 days, your unused pool becomes a beautiful, functional outdoor area — no heavy equipment or long construction delays required.
  - Future-Proof Flexibility: Unlike permanent solutions, this deck over swimming pool is fully removable, letting you restore the pool anytime — a smart move for resale or changing needs.
  - Family-Friendly Safety: By eliminating open water, you create a secure space for children, pets, and older family members — without sacrificing aesthetics.
  - Smart Investment: You gain a usable patio or entertainment zone without damaging your home’s value. In fact, many homeowners find that it enhances curb appeal.
  - Fewer Long-Term Surprises: Skip the structural risks, hidden landscaping issues, and resale red flags that come with traditional fill-ins. Building a deck over a swimming pool is a cleaner, safer path forward.

Feature Comparison: Pool Fill-In vs. Pool to Deck Conversion

Feature	Pool Fill-In	In-Pool Deck Conversion
Cost	$7K–$30K+	$12K–$25K+
Timeline	3–6 weeks	2–5 days
Reversible	No	Yes
Usable Space Immediately	Limited	Yes
Property Value Impact	Often negative	Maintains or increases
Safety Improvements	Limited	Immediate, safer surface

Real Homeowner Feedback

“I had a great experience with the whole team. From initial contact to the actual build, everyone had great communication. The deck is just beautiful.”

– Felicia Q., Las Vegas

“Wish I had done it sooner. The deck gave me back my yard without the mess of demolition.”

– John S., Gilbert

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a pool to deck conversion take?

Most projects are completed within 2–5 days, depending on pool size, access, and design complexity. Making it one of the fastest ways to create a pool that turns into patio.

Is the conversion permanent?

No. The removable deck over pool is fully reversible, allowing you to restore the pool at any time.

What materials are used?

Freedom Decks uses high-quality composite decking for durability, slip resistance, and low maintenance, supported by a proprietary bracket system.

Does this affect my home’s resale value?

Unlike a fill-in, a reversible conversion maintains flexibility, which is often seen as a plus for future buyers.

Conclusion: Why a Deck Conversion Is the Smarter Choice

A removable deck over pool offers flexibility, safety, and preserved home value, making it the superior alternative to a permanent pool fill-in. With quick installation and a fully reversible system, Freedom Decks helps you reclaim your backyard without long-term regrets.

Visit Freedom Decks to learn more about covering pool with deck solutions that protect your investment and transform your outdoor living space.

View full post