The True Cost to Get Rid of a Pool: Fill-In vs. Deck
Your inground pool has reached the end of its useful life. The kids have grown up, the maintenance has become a chore, and now it sits there—a big, water-filled question mark in the middle of your yard. Before you call a demolition crew, take a moment to think differently. Why destroy it when you can transform it? Creative homeowners are finding brilliant ways to repurpose your inground swimming pool into something unique and functional.
This isn't about simply covering it up; it's about reimagining the space. That concrete shell can be the foundation for a stunning new backyard feature. From sunken gardens to outdoor theaters, exploring these repurpose pool ideas can spark inspiration. While some are more practical than others, they all share a common goal: turning a liability into a lifestyle centerpiece. Let's dive into five creative alternatives that go beyond just filling the hole with dirt.
Idea 1: The Sunken Garden or Greenhouse
One of the most popular and visually stunning ideas is to convert your pool to garden. By transforming the pool into a sunken garden bed, you create a unique, multi-level landscape feature that becomes the focal point of your yard.
How It Works:
The process involves punching drainage holes in the pool floor, partially filling the deep end with gravel to level the surface, and then adding high-quality soil. The existing pool walls provide a natural retaining wall and create a sheltered microclimate, which can be ideal for growing plants that might not thrive elsewhere in your yard. For the ambitious gardener, a custom greenhouse structure can be built over the top, using the pool shell as a foundation.
The Reality Check:
While beautiful, this is not a simple weekend project.
- Drainage is Critical: If not engineered correctly, you can create a giant, muddy bathtub that drowns your plants and becomes a breeding ground for mosquitos.
- Accessibility: You need to build safe, sturdy steps or ramps to access and work in your new garden.
- Labor Intensive: Moving tons of gravel and soil into the pool is a massive physical undertaking. Maintenance can also be challenging in a sunken space.
- Reversibility: While not as permanent as a fill-in, converting it back to a pool would require excavating all the soil and gravel, making it a costly and messy job.
Idea 2: The Fire Pit and Conversation Lounge
Imagine stepping down into a cozy, intimate outdoor living room, shielded from the wind and centered around a beautiful fire pit. Converting your pool into a sunken lounge is a sophisticated way to create a dedicated space for entertaining.
How It Works:
This usually involves building a raised, load-bearing floor over the majority of the pool, leaving a sunken, circular, or square area in the center. This central space is finished with pavers or tile and outfitted with a gas fire pit and built-in seating along the walls. The surrounding raised floor provides a seamless transition to the rest of the yard.
The Reality Check:
This is a complex construction project requiring professional expertise.
- Engineering and Safety: The raised floor must be properly engineered to handle significant weight. Gas lines for the fire pit must be installed by a licensed professional, and proper ventilation is crucial to prevent carbon monoxide buildup in the sunken area.
- Cost: This is a high-end conversion. The cost of structural framing, decking, masonry, gas line installation, and built-in seating can easily exceed that of a standard deck conversion.
- Functionality: While stylish, it creates a very specific, single-purpose space that may not be as versatile as a flat, open patio.
Idea 3: The Koi Pond or Natural Water Feature
If you still love the idea of water but are tired of a chlorinated pool, converting it into a natural-looking pond is an option. Filled with aquatic plants, fish, and a waterfall, it can transform your backyard into a tranquil oasis.
How It Works:
The pool is drained, and the plaster surface is often covered with a rubber liner or natural rock finish. The deep end can be partially filled to create varying depths. A biological filtration system, completely different from a pool filter, is installed to keep the water healthy for fish and plants.
The Reality Check:
This is trading one type of maintenance for another.
- Specialized Systems: Maintaining a healthy ecosystem for fish is a science. It requires knowledge of water chemistry, filtration, and aquatic life.
- Predators and Pests: A koi pond can attract predators like raccoons and herons. It can also become a habitat for frogs and insects.
- Cost: Resurfacing the pool, installing a biological filter, and stocking it with high-quality koi and plants can be very expensive.
Idea 4: The In-Ground Trampoline or Sports Court
For families with active kids, repurposing the pool for recreation can seem like a great idea. This could involve installing a large, in-ground trampoline or converting the shallow end into a small sunken court for sports like paddle tennis or basketball.
How It Works:
For a trampoline, a support ledge is built around the inside of the pool walls, and the trampoline is stretched across the opening. For a sports court, the deep end is filled and leveled with the shallow end, and the entire surface is refinished with a suitable athletic coating.
The Reality Check:
Safety and usability are major concerns.
- Safety Hazards: An in-ground trampoline requires excellent drainage to prevent the pit from filling with water. The surrounding hard pool coping is a significant safety hazard.
- Limited Use: A small, sunken sports court has limited functionality and can feel cramped. The high walls can make ball games awkward.
- Niche Appeal: These are highly personalized features that can be a major turn-off for future buyers, potentially hurting resale value.
Idea 5: The Ultimate Solution—A Reversible, Full-Patio Deck Conversion
After exploring the creative but often complicated alternatives, the most practical, versatile, and financially sound solution for most homeowners is a full deck conversion. It addresses the core problem—the need for more functional outdoor space—without the drawbacks of the other options.
How It Works:
A specialist company like Freedom Decks installs a custom-engineered frame inside the pool shell. This frame supports a durable composite deck, transforming the entire area into a solid, safe, and beautiful patio. The process is fast (2-5 days), clean, and requires no heavy machinery.
The Unmatched Benefits:
- Maximum Versatility: It doesn't create a niche feature; it creates a blank canvas. Your new patio can be an outdoor dining room one night, a kids' play area the next day, and a quiet lounge space in the evening.
- Complete Reversibility: This is the only option that is truly and easily reversible. The pool structure remains completely intact, preserving its value for a future owner.
- Safety and Simplicity: It eliminates the open water hazard and creates a low-maintenance, easy-to-clean surface. There are no complex drainage systems to manage or niche features to maintain. It is the simplest way to retire my pool.
- Cost-Effective: While an investment, the cost to get rid of pool via a deck conversion is often less than high-end custom projects and provides far more value than a permanent fill-in.
The Smartest Way to Reimagine Your Yard
While the idea of a secret garden or a sunken lounge is romantic, the reality of these projects is often fraught with complexity, high costs, and questionable practicality. They solve the problem of the "ugly pool" by creating a new, potentially high-maintenance feature.
A reversible deck conversion, on the other hand, offers a clean, elegant, and overwhelmingly practical solution. It is the fastest and most efficient way to repurpose your inground swimming pool into usable square footage. It provides the freedom to design your backyard lifestyle exactly how you want it, with the peace of mind that you've made a smart, value-preserving investment in your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
What can I do with an old inground pool?
You have several options: permanently remove it (fill-in or demolition), repurpose it into a feature like a garden or pond, or transform it into usable living space with a reversible deck conversion. For most homeowners, a deck conversion offers the best balance of cost, usability, and value preservation.
Is it a good idea to turn a pool into a garden?
It can be a visually appealing project, but it requires careful planning to manage drainage and accessibility. If not engineered correctly, it can become a swampy pit. It is also labor-intensive to install and maintain, and costly to reverse if you or a future buyer want the pool back.
What is the cheapest way to repurpose a pool?
While a DIY garden conversion might seem cheapest upfront, it has hidden costs in materials and potential drainage problems. A professionally installed, reversible deck conversion is often the most cost-effective solution in the long run because it requires minimal maintenance, stops all pool-related expenses, and protects your property's resale value.
Tags: